Often this happens because it fails to enabled a TLS connection.
MC is using built in Windows functions for TLS negotiation, Not OpenSSL (that the others are using), (Support for OpenSSL is planed for the future..)
Problem is that MC is depending on what chiphers Windows support or has enabled, Windows support most of them but some of them that are not considers fully safe are disabled by default.
It is possible to enable them. With this tool
https://www.nartac.com/Products/IISCrypto/ you can modify that, But then you must know exactly what Chipers combination you need.