News:

MultiCommander v16.6 is released!

Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - koreb

#1
Quote from: Mathias (Author) on March 10, 2019, 17:18:17
It should work. I use it my self very often.
I'v tested many configuration (others clients: filezilla, winscp, totalcmd; ftpd: vsvftp,proftpd, diferrent phisical servers, different LANs)
100% - not NET problem or firewall - hard checked.
FTPD (proftd, vsftpd) configured with TLS connection only allowed.
Others clients with combination with any ftpd works fine.
Previously I wrote that only PASSIVE dont work (passive is my target:)), but after many others test (many many) I can say problem is in both active/passive.
MC works only with old version of vsftpd (v.2). When actual vesrion of any ftpd are installed then is a problem. Connection hangs after command: "LIST" (passive/active no matter always after LIST).
Reading rfc2228 i see before sending "PROT" client must send "PBSZ". MC does'nt do it. Maybe tha is the problem.
(and one other problem: MC cant support "require ssl reuse": but it's not important - I can switch off this in ftpd conf)

Bestregards.
#2
I checked TotalCommander, FileZilla and WinSCP(over FTP SSL), all connect with TLS with passive mod perfect.
Server and client both in one LAN. Iptables on server are clear - no rules, all policy 'accept'.
(MC without PASV with TLS works perfect, only passive+tls are problem)
If You use often this configuration Can I ask: what server do you use?

Bestregards
#3
Hello.
I tested this issue with two different ftp server: vsftpd, proftpd.
Problem occurs each time only if MultiCommander connect to FTP with TLS and passive mode.
Without passive is OK.
Connection Issue appears after:
MC send command PASV
server answer: 227 Entering passive mode ....
MC send LIST
MC log: = Opening data connection to IP <"server and passive port">
server answer: 150 ...
and after that... after some seconds ....
MC log: = Error reading secure data from the server. (Error : 10060)

Bestregards